The Garden of Bagatelle, Paris

Visit to Bagatelle, May 2011

Bagatelle was a disappointment. Partly it was the effort getting there. My guidebook rather unhelpfully listed various metro stops and left it at that, and it was off the edge of their map. I made the mistake of picking Sablons as the metro stop, since it was subtitled Jardin d’Acclimitation, which seemed a good beginning, but it was a hike of several kilometres along an unattractive, badly signposted road. For the record, you go by Metro to Porte Maillot, where there is the terminus of the 244 bus. This goes straight down the Allé de Longchamp. You get off after a few stops at Bagatelle Pré Catelan. This is in the middle of nowhere, so don’t expect visual cues. You look for the path on the same side as the bys by running of 45 degrees towards the back.  This takes you to the Grille d’Honneur. The real main entrance is on the other side, at Grille Sevres, but the Grille d’Honneur entrance is the most direct.

The Grille d’Honneur is a lovely rococo wrought iron gate in gold and green, which was a promising beginning (Fig. 1). Less promising was the condition of the little pavilion beside it (Fig. 2) which is derelict and boarded up. This cues you to the fact that you are in a municipal garden (Mairie de Paris) where nobody really cares. Quest-Ritson calls it the best garden in Paris, which does not encourage one to explore Parisian gardens further. (No doubt he is referring to the roses.) At the Grille d’Honneur you are in the middle of the top side of what is a long thin plot. I hadn’t had lunch so sought out the restaurant marked on the map near the Grille de Sevres on the other side. This turned out to be a wonderful nineteenth-century building, with fancy woodwork in red, and where the food was 29 euros for an entrée (Fig. 3). There was a group lunch for prosperous oldies going on. I was directed by the information woman to ‘le snack’ back on the other side. As usual in such places, the only edible things are soft drink and packaged ice cream. This seems to be the norm in France: overpriced restaurants and terrible snack booths and nothing in-between.

‘Le Snack’ is  near Le Grand Rocher and the central part of the Jardin Anglo-Chinois, so I started here. Le Grand Rocher is a tall construction with a waterfall coming off the top (Fig. 4). It is so like the little waterfalls you see in paintings by Claude that I think it was modelled on one. You can’t get up it (the entrance is a workplace for gardeners), but you get to see it from the front a bit further on. There were one of two people on the lawns round about, as in the Melbourne Botanical Gardens, but being so far from anywhere there were not many. The grass was yellowing and going to seed, as there was a drought on, though it was only the end of May. It was all rather Australian, and less lush than the Melbourne Botanical Gardens in summer. It make you realise how much European gardens depend on their lush greenness for their effect.

The next feature was the Grotto des Quatre Vents. This has a pale blue wrought iron pavilion on top (Fig. 5) although not the one engraved by Percier and Fontaine or La Rouge that is in all the books (Fig. 6). The grotto itself was somewhat Claudian, in the way it formed a promontory composed of two rocky arches, with the tempietto-pavilion perched on the top of the last one (Fig. 7). This motif appears a lot in early Claude, including the painting in Houston (Fig. 8). The arches themselves are composed of big, sharp slabs, and were pleasingly open and energetic; not lumpish like the rock mountain at Ripponlea (Fig. 9). Beneath the pavilion it formed a kind of cave, which would have made a good picnic room (Fig. 10). The openness and structural nature of the rockery worked well with this thinness of the wrought iron of the pavilion. In this case you could climb up to the pavilion on top. The iron is rusting, and needs maintenance before it is too late (Fig. 11). I am not a great fan of wrought iron, which tends to be thin and fussy. But this was more interesting than most, quite ethereal. The balustrades were formed by thin rods about 5 mm in diameter forming a basket weave (Fig. 12).

Down below you can see a large green copper urn on a pedestal at the junction of nearby paths (Fig. 13). Unlike Chinese fibreglass-concrete imitations, this was real copper, but it looked just as fake.

Then came is the Grotto beside the Black Swan Lake (though I didn’t see any swans of any colour). This had the conceit of being a cave you entered from behind with a waterfall sheet, or rather dribbles, screening the view of a bridge opposite (Fig. 14).  The fall landed on some rocks placed there for the purpose. Across the water you see a bridge (Fig. 15). All of these features are rather like Wörlitz, but devoid of its magic.

Across the bridge is the ruins of the abbey of Longchamp. I assume these are real ruins. To stop you going in there are hurdles and two trees in Versailles planters dumped in front (Fig. 16). Charming.  After that you turn right and enter a circular space framed by little pavilions faming a view of the main pavilion, grandly called the Chateau (Fig. 17). This circular space is ringed by statues, apparently the originals judging from the weathering, which include the Belvedere Antinous (Fig. 18). But you can hardly see these because of big square boards placed in front of them, seemingly waiting for posters or something, or maybe to protect the statues from ball games or something. It makes you appreciate the National Trust. There is a cour d’honneur between this and the Chateau, with another building, the Trianon, along one side. The entrance to the Trianon had a blocking structure as well (Fig. 19). Peering into the Chateau you could see a sign saying they had guided tours at 3 pm every day,  but it was 3 pm and obviously northing happening (Fig. 20). There is a parterre of tepid interest beyond, that, and other features on the north side, but I didn’t go there.

Coming past the restaurant on the west side you enter a long formal garden, the Jardin de Presentation along the boundary wall (Fig. 21). Here I met the lunch group. This was impressive. There was an avenues down the middle covered mostly with wisteria, with box beds on either side. At the entrance to the avenue were two cute little herms, about 1.4 m high (Fig. 22). They had child-faun heads (Fig. 23) and their toes peeped out of the foot of the shaft (Fig. 24). Along the boundary wall was high trellis with climbing roses. This really worked, and is something to aspire to (Fig. 25).

(to be concluded)

 

Posted in Baroque Gardens, Design, Fabriques, Garden History | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

A Curious Impost Block at Iford Manor

At Harold Peto’s Iford Manor by there is a neo-Romanesque pavilion called the Casita on the upper terrace. Its wonderfully weathered architrave is supported on double stone columns with fused capitals (apparently pink Verona marble dating from c. 1200) with an impost block between. This impost block appears to be composed of three pieces of wood dovetailed (or rather straight-tailed) together, as if the side pieces were hinged on the central one. One begins by wondering why Peto has done this. The purpose of an impost block is to spread the load between architrave and capital, a task which an intact piece of wood would do better, although in the end any structural difference would be negligible. Perhaps his pieces of wood were too short? Then one realizes that the grain of the wood continues through all three pieces of wood: it is in fact a single piece of wood after all. The wood has been carved in such a way as to give the impression that there are ‘dovetails’: they are fictive.  What game is Peto playing here? Is it a sophisticated neo-Mannerist trick? Does it have a precedent in Romanesque architecture? Whatever the reason, it is a delightful conceit. If forces us to swivel the hinged sides of the impost in our mind’s eye, and that makes it very interesting for the way it manipulates the spectator’s response. Also intriguing is the profile of the side pieces (which we must now call ends) of the impost block, which are more Chinese than Romanesque. And how did his carpenter make it? Cutting thick pieces of wood is a nightmare. The only tool which comes near is a bandsaw, and even a bandsaw will not do such sharp curves as these. The deep hollows would have been drilled; the rest probably involved templates, or outlines on either side and a series of straight sawcuts, with lots of chiselling.

Robin Whalley’s book on Peto states that the ‘highly decorative architrave’ is ‘probably of Venetian origin’. I am not clear whether he means by this the style is Venetian, and the manufacture local, or that the wood is actually old and Venetian (if follows mention of the columns being of Verona marble). Peto apparently was thinking of Spain, as H. Avray Tipping in 1922 expained that a casita was ‘a Spanish form of loggia’, but Whalley says ‘aspects of its construction are borrowed mainly from Italy’. (Robin Whalley, The Great Edwardian Gardens of Harold Peto. From the archives of Country Life, London: Aurum Press, 2007, p. 177.)

Posted in All Posts, Architecture, Art, Construction, Design, English Gardens, Fabriques, Garden History | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

The Impossibility of Australian Architectural Connoisseurship

‘An Australian, however well-informed, simply cannot distinguish between a piece of Trust House timbering and a genuine Tudor building; an Englishman however uncultured knows at once …’. [Evelyn Waugh to John Betjeman, cited in A.N. Wilson’s Biography of Betjeman, 2007, p. 170. Actually an analogy with Catholics and Anglo-Catholics all looking alike to Betjeman, according to Waugh.]

Evelyn Waugh having thus established the impossibility of an Australian engaging in architectural connoisseurship, it  may be unwise to embark on this theme. And perhaps he is right, given how dreadful is the builder’s mock Federation, worse perhaps than the mock-Tudor thirties semi-detached so hated by early twentieth-century British architectural aesthetes.

A builder was describing to be a building he had recently clad in blackbutt, and how it expanded and buckled with time. The modernist preoccupation with new materials has carried over into Australian domestic housing, where the aspirational who want to make a statement feel it is necessary to  experiment with untried materials. There is a lot of this in Grand Designs too. But in the end aesthetic pleasure derives from getting the shape right. Better to focus on shape and appearance, and use established materials. Weatherboard is good example of such a material. Being basically the same technique used for boats from the Vikings onwards, it can flex and bend and still work even if the structure behind is falling apart and the stumps are gone. And the regular parallel lines provide a pleasing enlivening of the surface, helped by the necessary small irregularities.

Posted in All Posts, Architecture, Comment, Garden History | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

On Baroque Gardens

I picked up Tim Richardson’s The Arcadian Friends. Inventing the English Landscape Garden at the local remainder bookshop. Although the subject is the landscape garden it has an unusually sensitive account of the Baroque garden: ‘there is a tendency today to view this kind of seventeenth-century ‘formality’—what a strange term for it!—as sterile and lifeless.’ [I have had this point of view expressed with some force by a publisher of gardening books who ought to have known better.]  … But the one thing that has become clear from experiencing recently restored baroque gardens on the ground is how intimate and engaging they can be. … Far from being sterile, ‘unnatural’ experiments in geometry, as their unadorned remains have so often suggested to us and as they can appear in contemporary topographical bird’s-eye views, in their day these gardens surrounded visitors with fragrant flowers. Looking at a contemporary engravings by Johannes Kip it is all to easy to be overwhelmed by the linearity and to forget that these gardens had an intimate aspect; you need to imagine that you have been beamed down into the place and can walk amid the trees, fruit and flowers.’ [p. 18]

More than that is the fact that a design that is conceived in plan, and then ‘extruded’ in relief by plantings, when seen from ground level becomes infinitely complex. You perceive that there is an underlying order, but what you see is a visual field of great complexity. In a genuinely natural or random planting you see only a disorderly visual field, without the underling order that your perception seeks to comprehend.  Hence although parterres can often be seen to advantage from a high viewpoint, this is not always necessary. Head height is often as high as you need to go, and if you go too high the parterre becomes too obvious. To illustrate these points, the first three images shows a platte-bande at Fontainebleau, to show how the experience up close is intensely involved with plants. The repetition of the planting and colours makes you much more aware of the flowers than if they were planted more randomly. The fourth image shows a parterre that I have always felt does not quite work: at the Palazzo Ruspoli at Vignanello. The high view from the palazzo is almost too high, while the close view lacks an engagement with plants: there is only box. This green and flowerless garden is essentially an early twentieth-century Italian construct, the result of an attempt to define nationalistically the ‘Italian’ garden style as opposed to the French and English styles. Before this it would have been planted with flowers within the box, and before that… what? It is claimed to be a surviving Renaissance garden, a box parterre like those seen in the Dupérac engraving of the Villa d’Este, but one wonders whether it was not rather a low parterre de broderie with coloured gravel. The Villa Lante and Villa Doria-Pamphilj parterres were once of this form, as old photos clearly show, but have grown up to become dense green high box parterres like those at Vignanello.

Posted in All Posts, Baroque Gardens, Book Commentaries, Garden History | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment